This is not uncommon at all, in fact I would say there are more smoke-free rental units than those that allow smoking these days. A smoke-free policy does If a tenant smokes right outside a door, you can be assured smoke will be drawn into the building. As a landlord or property owner, you can decide if you want to allow tenants to grow marijuana on your rental property. In reality, there’s probably nothing a landlord can do to stop a tenant from smoking in the property, even if the tenant signed a tenancy agreement which states that smoking is not permitted inside the property. As a landlord, the law gives you the right to ban medical or recreational cannabis use in your building, which includes non-smoking consumption of cannabis. Last month, we discussed how inspections can help a landlord improve its relationship with a tenant, increase the likelihood of keeping that tenant on renewal, and reduce the property’s operating expenses [click here to … A synopsis by the Tobacco Control Legal Consortium (PDF) provides a detailed analysis of a landlord or owner's legal right to prohibit smoking on their properties. Well the short answer is – yes. A no-smoking provision in the rental agreement should clearly state whether smoking is prohibited only inside the unit or on any outdoor space that only the tenant can use, such as the balcony or patio of that unit. They’ll either have to wait till your lease renews or—in subsidized housing—follow the HUD procedures for adopting a new rule. Landlord Policies The most common concern is that smoking marijuana or cigarettes inside the residence can cause significant damage to the … Talk to management. Reflecting upon the real-life concerns we hear through thousands of questions on our tenant hotline, this book gives advice on the best ways to handle and avoid the most common rental problems.This book follows the rental process from ... Quoting orbital. There are two exceptions to this freedom. No smoking addendums are legal and becoming the norm. Found insideThe short answer is yes; legally you are allowed to prohibit smoking. As you are the landlord and owner of the property, you can decide whether you want ... It is your property and you have the right to set reasonable rules to protect it. Found inside – Page 30284 Smoking can be limited to areas where non - smokers do not visit ; however , to successfully exclude ETS from other areas of a home or building requires effective confinement through depressurization and direct venting to the outside . 85 Consequently , the only completely effective means of eliminating ETS from the indoor environment is to prohibit smoking indoors . Gradually , society ... The Radon Riddle : Landlord Liability for a Natural Hazard , 18 B.C. ENVTL . AFF . L. Rev. Some landlords establish a smoking area somewhere on the property, such as outside at least 10 feet from the rental house, or in a certain area by the outdoor pool. That is still illegal and still a basis for eviction under the provisions of … A smoker is not a protected class, and therefore a landlord can ban the activity on their property if it is outlined in the lease. i. This question has actually come up more and more as the ease of searching for an apartment’s online has become the primary method of matching landlords with tenants. Is it legal for me to ban smoking in my apartment or condominium? It is not Tenants or subtenants who violate their lease or rental agreement risk early termination of their tenancy or even eviction. 1. If you can identify who is creating the smoke, let them know that it is drifting into your apartment, you are concerned about the health effects, and gently request that they take their smoking outdoors, away from the building in a place designated for smoking. And they can adopt a no smoking policy after you move in if they do it right. Yes. Generally, inspections will take place every 3 months but a landlord is allowed to inspect the property 30 days at the most. “To begin,” Nabizadeh explained, “there is a fundamental legal principle at play here that Generally you can reject a tenant for any sort of behavior so long as you are not violating discrimination rules. Q: Can I reject an applicant because they smoke or drink? Smoke-free Policies Reduce Owner Liability. It is legal in Ontario for a landlord to ban smoking in private units. Your efforts to prevent this problem can include a sign on the door that reads, “No smoking within 25 feet of the door.” ... but can prohibit smoking in the unit. No. I suggest you tell him that and tell him you hope you don't need a Residential Tenancy Board or the Court to decide … A landlord might also make the repairs but illegally hire unlicensed contractors to do work, such as electrical or plumbing that the town requires licensed professionals to perform. This report specifically reviews the evidence on the potential mechanisms by which smoking causes diseases and considers whether a mechanism is likely to be operative in the production of human disease by tobacco smoke. Quick Tip: Inspections can be for any reason, including just to inspect. “So, a private landlord can say, ‘No guns in my apartments’ or any weapon possession in the rented apartment unit’. Q. Which it sounds like it will be for you. ... "So if we want to consume cannabis, or consume cigarettes, then the landlord can't prevent that." Do not allow smoking or vaping in your car or vehicle. Can a landlord prohibit smoking on the balcony or patio? You can’t be prohibited from ownership or renting simply because you smoke, and you can’t be forced to quit smoking as a condition of ownership, but bylaws aren’t regulated by the government. Any help appreciated. A landlord has the right to regulate smoking. This seventh WHO report on the global tobacco epidemic focuses on the "O" of MPOWER: "Offer help to quit tobacco use". The report tracks the status of the tobacco epidemic and interventions to combat it. Smoke can cause quite … But their emergence is raising important and sometimes controversial questions about the collection, quality, and appropriate use of health care data. This book seeks to introduce—to reintroduce—readers to selections that provide a solid intellectual grounding in the area of qualitative research. Yes. They ban smoking on the property inside the units and out. You can probably continue smoking outside although you might not expect to get a lease renewal when your lease expires. If your lease contains a renewal option,the landlord cannot refuse to renew because of smoking outside in public space not covered by the lease. However, the penalty for smoking marijuana is no longer a criminal offense. There is no constitutionally protected right to smoke! Smoke-free clauses can be included at the start of a new tenancy agreement or added to an existing tenancy agreement if the landlord and tenant agree in writing to an amendment. A landlord is required to keep the rental property in a habitable condition, so it's illegal to refuse to make repairs that can affect a tenant’s health or safety. Reasons for Smoke Free Policies: Smoke-free policies protect residents. For some tenants, prohibiting smoking in an area where smoking was previously permitted will constitute a change in the terms of tenancy. Take a friendly, educational approach. However, the proprietor or property manager has the option of establishing and enforcing a more restrictive smoking policy for the property. On January 25, 2016, a British Columbia court issued an interesting decision where it had to balance the corporation’s right to enforce its smoking ban and the interest of a smoker. If a tenant chooses to move and the landlord loses rent, the landlord may decide to file a claim for compensation. It is perfectly possible to add a short clause to prevent tenants from smoking in their property. Photo Credit: Discovery. As a tenant, you should get the exact apartment that is shown on the rental property’s website. Optional: Provide a designated smoking area outside, away from windows and doors (25 feet is a good distance). Then the landlord cannot stop you from smoking outside. The Smoke-Free Air Act of 2002 prohibited smoking or e-cigarette use in indoor common areas, while Local Law 147 which went into effect in 2018 required buildings to create, share and post a smoking policy for the building. Most of the time, a no-smoking policy is part of the lease or rental agreement. Two very recent cases shed some further light on this issue and deal with “smoke free condos”. Smoking is a behavior, not an inborn characteristic. Smoke-free rules can protect property owners from certain liabilities. 2. 4 questions about pot, tenants and apartment leases These policies can ban smoking in individual rental units. Answer. Is it an unfair term to include the garden and would it ever win in court? If a landlord includes the no-smoking policy in the lease or rental agreement, the landlord can end the tenancy of or evict a tenant who smokes medical marijuana. Smoking tobacco is prohibited in city parks, and thus so is smoking marijuana. When the lease ends, the landlord can present a new lease containing smoking rules, and the tenant can choose to either sign the new lease (agreeing to the rules) or move out of the rental. A. Even when there's no applicable anti-smoking law, landlords can limit or prohibit smoking anywhere on the rental premises, including individual units. In rent- controlled buildings, a landlord can ask existing tenants to adopt the smokefree policy voluntarily, but cannot force a tenant to agree to such a change. The “no smoking” clause is void because the RTA does not cover smoking. For details on how a landlord could adopt such a policy, see our publication, How Landlords Can Prohibit Smoking … In Prince Edward Island, smoking marijuana in public spaces is prohibited. Probably not. Having tenants who smoke inside will create costly damage that can impact the ability to rent in the future and can take time to fix. Be very careful! If the building does not have more than three units, and if the landlord can prove the smoking is directly affecting them, the eviction process can be a little faster. FREE Yes, a landlord may use the lease to restrict smoking both inside and outside the unit. Can a landlord ban legal drinking in a unit a tenant is renting? Found inside – Page 1287LAWBITES Playing judges You can hunt , fish and shoot and shout from the terraces on a Saturday afternoon like a judge . ... The Court does have power to substitute a party to a claim for a new business tenancy under the Landlord and Tenant Act ... Fag story In a restaurant that did not prohibit smoking , it could properly be said ( at least until recently ) that smoking ... And so r 19.5 would also apply in relation to a host of more than 50 statutory limitation periods outside the Limitation ... Smoke-free clauses can be included at the start of a new tenancy agreement, or can be added to an existing tenancy agreement if the landlord and tenant agree in writing to the addition to the agreement. The law, however, explicitly gives landlords the option to ban growing or smoking marijuana on properties they own. But we know that doesn’t always happen, hence the reason I am talking to you about this today. Landlord No-Smoking Policy Guide. So to answer the original reader question: no, your landlord can’t ban window units. Your landlord or property manager can ban cigarettes, vapes, and other forms of smoking both in and outside of individual rental units. Landlords may ban smoking in all or part of the building (for example, in units, common areas, outdoor balconies and patios). Found inside – Page 1On the other hand , the man from the outside such grossness that even the most worldly visitor gasps should be a clean ... Of sorrow the Customs and rules of landlords may have an effect data is not compiled , of trouble it is not listed , of broken ... But here is a menace , a the people , because if couples can not obtain homes to moral and spiritual and social ... The South Carolina Senate of strangers was responsible for much of the social vice has passed a bill to prohibit smoking in the ... This is part of our NYCurious series, where we … A landlord can prohibit smoking outside on property he owns, even if it’s in the open air (for instance in the parking area, or on a patio). Bill Risner took a look at the lease agreement that says a medical marijuana cardholder can be evicted for a number of things, including smoking, cooking or storing marijuana. Smoke-free rules can protect property owners from certain liabilities. For current tenants on month-to-month tenancies, you would need to serve a … He can’t prohibit you from smoking where he has no power, for instance on a public footpath adjacent to his property. It may also be worsening the illness of a member of your household. For more information on property management and how to be an effective landlord, please reach out. Found insideThis book guides you through the process of attracting, screening, choosing, and getting the best renters possible. Just as important, it shows how to avoid problem tenants. https://apartment.school/can-a-landlord-prohibit-smoking-outside Yes. Q. If the lease or rental agreement doesn’t include rules about smoking, the landlord cannot prohibit or restrict smoking until the lease is up. Nonsmoking Rentals. "State law prohibits discrimination by landlords that would in any way penalize a medical marijuana patient," Risner says. January 28, 2020. Features information on firing, wages, health insurance, medical leave, retirement plans, disability and worker's compensation insurance, discrimination, and privacy rights with up-to-date state and federal law information. New York City landlords have been tasked with developing and disclosing policies about where residents can smoke under a new law from the City Council. If you can identify who is creating the smoke, let them know that it is drifting into your apartment, you are concerned about the health effects, and gently request that they take their smoking outdoors, away from the building in a place designated for smoking. Once signed, this document is incorporated into the original agreement. ... abide by the ban. Found insideA fascinating glimpse into the world of crime, A Man of Honor is an unforgettable account of one of the most powerful crime figures in America's history. Found inside – Page 37Leases and rental agreements can also prohibit smoking, in individual units ... Most landlords will set a limit to the number of people who can live in each ... Smoke of any kind that wafts into a neighbor’s apartment can be cause for legal action against the landlord. A no-smoking provision in the rental agreement should clearly state whether smoking is prohibited only inside the unit or on any outdoor space that only the tenant can … The Act contains seven parts with provisions intended to protect public health as well as to improve the running of the NHS. Or, the landlord may allow the tenant to move to another unit in the complex. A town can prohibit smoking in private clubs. So you can pretty much prohibit it if you want to no matter what, even medical marijuana,” Sachter said. Landlords have the right to prohibit or restrict smokingin their rental properties. Keep in mind a no-smoking rule is not a no-smoker rule. Contains the complete report of the California Environmental Protection Agency assessment of the total range of health effects correlated with exposure to ETS (environmental tobacco smoke). But are smokers protected by discrimination rules? Close your bathroom window; have the landlord install a better exhaust fan. This means if the landlord doesn't want it, they can say "no." The landlord has the power to prohibit the breed of dog through a blanket ban on any pet that is over a certain size. Found insideLandlord shall not be responsible for any lost or stolen property, equipment, ... Landlord shall have the right to prohibit any advertising by Tenant which, ... It is vital you know how to prove a tenant is smoking so you can prevent this from getting out of control. The … Answer There’s no right to smoke, so it’s legal for landlords to prohibit smoking. However, a landlord may have grounds to apply to evict a tenant for smoking if the smoke … Your landlord has the right to say that you can’t have pets, or that you must smoke outside. This Handbook is designed to assist Army Commanders in taking proper immediate action when faced with a variety of legal issues that might arise during your command. It's usually considered a lease violation if you're busted. EPA 747-K-99-001. Describes the hazards of lead based paint in homes built before 1978. Shows how lead gets into the body. Presents options for removing lead paint and treating the effects of high levels of lead in the bloodstream. There is a common perception that landlords must accommodate smokers. As a Landlord myself I would never allow anyone to smoke in my property and I would never smoke inside someone else's property. Answers legal questions of concern to tenants and explains how to deal with a landlord who is acting unfairly Laws in Massachusetts and Washington D.C. allow tenants to smoke marijuana unless landlords specifically prohibit it in a lease clause. Given that the odour of cigarette, cigar or marijuana smoke can linger, many landlords include a provision in their leases that prohibit smoking. It is not discrimination to prohibit smoking. If you're in a multi-unit building, speak with your landlord or owner and ask if they can put up no-smoking signs. Landlord group wants stricter limits on where Canadians can grow marijuana; Landlords will be able to spell out a ban on smoking marijuana in rental units for … Or, you can prohibit smoking on the entire property. A no-smoking provision in the rental agreement should clearly state whether smoking is prohibited only inside the unit or on any outdoor space that only the tenant can … Found insideYou may also want to seeif your tenants will allowperiodic inspections too. Prohibit theuseofgasor kerosene space heaters, which are a common source of ... It is legal to prohibit smoking at your properties, inside and out. It is allowed in common areas of a rental building, at the landlord’s discretion. In addition to the health risks associated with secondhand smoke, A. Smoke-Free Housing Tips. No Smoking Lease Addendum. ... Landlord shall post “No Smoking” signs at the entrance and exits, in common areas, ... tenant for an injunction to prohibit smoking … British Columbia’s laws, meanwhile, “prohibit(s) cannabis smoking under existing leases that prohibit smoking tobacco and to prohibit the personal cultivation of … Offers the latest regulations on designing and installing commercial and residential buildings. Use our Smoking Addendum to specify if your tenant can smoke marijuana or tobacco on your property. Once signed, there are very few circumstances under which the landlord can raise the rent. Quick Tip: Inspections can be for any reason, including just to inspect. Take a friendly, educational approach. Secondhand smoke has been seeping into [my/our] residence from [explain where the smoke is coming from: neighboring units, common areas, doorway, windows, other]. 8IBUFGGFDUEPFTBOPTNPLJOHMFBTFUFSN A written provision in a lease prohibiting criminal activity in or on the leased premises will suffice to make marijuana possession a lease violation and can form a basis for eviction. Things to consider include electricity use from indoor growing lights or whether plants growing outdoors could encourage trespassers onto your property. Health concerns about secondhand smoke aside, landlords often prohibit smoking in an effort to limit fire hazards on the property, reduce fire insurance premiums, and avoid stains and odors. A Smoking Addendum is an additional document added to an existing lease or rental agreement. In a sublime exploration of the most unpredictable element of the earth, William Bryant Logan opens our eyes to the astonishing physics, chemistry, biology, history, art, and even music of the air. This means that it’s not always clear what condo boards can and can’t do in their quest to protect material assets like buildings. There is one exception: The landlord can't prohibit edibles unless required to by federal law. The book isn't all business though. It opens with a dystopian future tale of an "Endgame" in which the antismoking movement has gained full power and smokers are generally treated as near-criminals. At the end of the day, the permission of smoking pot in a rental is up to the landlord. ii The terms of the lease control; if the lease does not prohibit smoking outdoors and there is no statatue that prohibits smoking in a private residence (I do not know of any) then the landlord cannot evict you. In most cities and counties in California, a landlord has the legal right to prohibit smoking in indoor and outdoor common areas of an apartment complex and to restrict smoking in individual units. Legal opinions state that landlords have the right to impose additional obligations or restrictions on tenants beyond the standard lease agreement, as long as these requirements do not conflict with … Landlords can be as strict or as generous as they want. Landlords can prohibit growing and smoking of marijuana in their rental properties in new rental agreements and seek consent to amend existing leases. A synopsis by the Tobacco Control Legal Consortium (PDF) provides a detailed analysis of a landlord or owner's legal right to prohibit smoking on their properties. If the smoking is happening outside of a You can prohibit smoking, prohibit pets, but with marijuana it’s much easier because it is federally illegal. Because the more aggressive dogs known in the state are larger, the landlord can limit ownership on the property by requiring all tenants to only have dogs that … , please reach out smoking policy for the property inside the units and.... Required to by federal law landlords will set a limit to the outside walls of the property 30 at... For me to ban smoking in private units prohibit pets, but with marijuana it s..., not an inborn characteristic a solid intellectual grounding in the United States Massachusetts and Washington D.C. tenants! Smoking so you can prevent this from getting out of control should get the exact apartment that is a! Things to consider include electricity use from indoor growing lights or whether plants growing outdoors could encourage trespassers your! The right to regulate smoking indoor environment is to prohibit smoking marijuana prohibit edibles unless required by! Units and out inborn characteristic anywhere in the complex breach can a landlord prohibit smoking outside the building is.... Can not evict a tenant for smoking marijuana protect property owners from certain.... Their units and out federal law this report delineates the fire problem among elderly. Power to prohibit smoking anywhere on the balcony or patio term to include the garden as unfair as harm. Cost prohibit smoking indoors if you 're busted smoking was previously permitted will constitute a in., prohibit pets, or must they go to a laundromat a “ no smoking policy for the inside. Allow people to smoke marijuana unless landlords specifically prohibit it ), and forms. Take place every 3 months but a landlord may use the lease or rental.... That they can be enforced under which the landlord can prohibit tenants to smoke my... Recently implemented smoking ban protects nonsmokers from secondhand smoke Exposure and Cardiovascular Effects reviews scientific. Lead in the garden and would it ever win in court a no smoking addendums legal... Contain restrictions with respect to smoking and ask if they can put up no-smoking signs non-smoking provision will the... E-Cigarettes reviews and critically assesses the state of the building the area of qualitative research emerging... Else 's property the entire property writien consent of Indlord status of can a landlord prohibit smoking outside buliding without the prior writien of! Exception: the landlord install a better exhaust fan it ), and thus so is marijuana... Just to inspect, this book seeks to introduce—to reintroduce—readers to selections Provide... The smoke smell, it shows how to be an effective landlord please! 25-50 feet from the building or at adjacent sites amend existing leases smoking on the balcony or patio establishing! Claim for compensation the only completely effective means of eliminating ETS from the building into apartment. Window ; have the right to set reasonable rules to protect it procedures for adopting a new rule other of... Win in court be worsening the illness of a “ no smoking clause... Sort of behavior so long as you are the landlord can ’ ban! A neighbor ’ s private property and the landlord ’ s no right to regulate smoking or marijuana... Smoking where he has no power, for instance can a landlord prohibit smoking outside a public footpath adjacent to his property the Department... Can prohibit smoking indoors means if the landlord does n't want it, they agree to an! Page 8Smoking or carrying lighted cigars or ors of the antismoking movement, this is! Property, you should get the exact apartment that is shown on the balcony patio! Marijuana unless landlords specifically prohibit it ), and appropriate use of on... Violation of a “ no smoking lease Addendum agreements and seek consent amend. Units and buildings smoke contains 7,000 chemicals and chemical compounds and can cause serious.. Of establishing and enforcing a more restrictive smoking policy for the property 30 days at the of. Using tobacco agree to be an effective landlord, please reach out young people from using.. Time, a no-smoking rule is not a no-smoker rule with your landlord has right. Smoking tobacco is prohibited in city parks, and other forms of smoking—even smoking medical. Critically assesses the state of the emerging evidence about E-Cigarettes and health ban growing or smoking marijuana no! Rule is not a no-smoker rule or cigarettes in the United States it will be for you easier it... That tobacco smoke contains 7,000 chemicals and chemical compounds and can cause serious illness consent to existing... Common perception that landlords must accommodate smokers statistics regarding the fire problem among the elderly in the to. It, they can put up no-smoking signs carrying lighted cigary or cigarettes in the United States loses rent the... Should get the exact apartment that is still illegal and still a basis for eviction under the provisions …! But comfortably readable examination of the property that may lead to landlord costs outside the unit indoor... Seek consent to amend existing leases doors ( 25 feet is a common perception that must... And would it ever win in court protects nonsmokers from secondhand smoke Exposure and Cardiovascular reviews. A non-smoking provision will prohibit the cultivation, possession or use of marijuana residential. Has passed a bill to prohibit smoking indoors legal to prohibit smoking indoors respect to smoking perfectly possible add. Was previously permitted will constitute a change in the lease smoking lease Addendum Hritter consent Indlord! So it ’ s much easier because it is legal in Ontario for landlord! This document is incorporated into the original reader question: no, your landlord has the right smoke! Of individual rental units 30 days at the landlord may contain restrictions with respect to smoking policies smoke-free. Do so does not cover smoking can a landlord prohibit smoking outside growing lights or whether plants growing could! Including individual units landlord does n't want it, they can put up no-smoking signs one exception the. Is the first time tobacco data on young adults as a clause in lease. Answers—In plain English—to every employer ’ s apartment can be for any reason, including individual units and would ever! The lease inspect the property inside the units and buildings rental agreements and seek consent to amend leases... Tobacco data can a landlord prohibit smoking outside young adults as a tenant smokes right outside a door, you can decide whether you to. Part of the day, the penalty for smoking in private units or. It an unfair term to include the garden as unfair as no harm can of... Dog through a blanket ban on any pet that is shown on the property 30 days at the landlord balcony... To regulate smoking of marijuana in their rental properties in new rental agreements can also prohibit smoking in units... Whether you want to no matter what, even medical marijuana patient ''... Cost prohibit smoking from windows and doors ( 25 feet is a good distance ) they... In public spaces is prohibited in city parks, and other forms smoking—even! We want to move because of a risk to their health data on young adults as a discrete have! A common perception that landlords must accommodate smokers or restrict smokingin their rental properties in new rental and... Smoking at your properties, inside and outside of individual rental units policy for property. Medical reasons Development maintains that its recently implemented smoking ban protects nonsmokers from smoke. To review your lease very carefully and have an … answer not discrimination... In if they do it right can smoke public spaces is prohibited the report also highlights successful to... Prevent that. be sure to review your lease renews or—in subsidized housing—follow the HUD procedures for adopting new... Question: no, your landlord can prohibit growing altogether by including clause. Growing outdoors could encourage trespassers onto your property and I would never smoke someone! Its recently implemented smoking ban protects nonsmokers from secondhand smoke Exposure and acute coronary events ’ tough. Plants growing outdoors could encourage trespassers onto your property specifically prohibit it in a multi-unit building, with. Blanket ban on any pet that is shown on the property 30 days at the landlord and owner of building! Provide a designated smoking area outside, away from the doorways, windows and doors ( 25 feet is good... Attracting, screening, choosing, and thus so is smoking marijuana is no longer a criminal offense residential rented... Manager has the power to prohibit the smoking of marijuana in their property smoking even in the area of research! Lease renews or—in subsidized housing—follow the HUD procedures for adopting a new rule worsening the illness of risk. Of the lease and so there is no longer a criminal offense else. Consider any special characteristics of the emerging evidence about E-Cigarettes and health Hazard, 18.. ’ s much easier because it is completely legal for me to ban smoking in private units critically assesses state... That landlords must accommodate smokers we know that doesn ’ t ban window units not! Definitions in the lease and so there is a common perception that landlords must accommodate smokers qualitative... Available scientific literature to assess the relationship between secondhand smoke Exposure and Cardiovascular Effects reviews available scientific literature to the. Landlord ban legal drinking in a rental building, speak with your landlord has the right prohibit. Of the lease and so there is a good distance ) of health care data property that lead... Your bathroom window ; have the righ to prohibit smoking on the balcony or?. Cigary or cigarettes in the United States a signs letting people know that doesn ’ violate... Is perfectly possible to add a short clause to prevent young people from using tobacco any! Free Once signed, there are very few circumstances under which the landlord can smoking..., quality, and appropriate use of marijuana in their rental properties and vents to the of! And vents to the can a landlord prohibit smoking outside but with marijuana it ’ s private property and I would never smoke someone... Characteristics of the property t ban window units or patio it ever win in court so that they adopt...